We use firebase to authenticate a frontend application in the standard process- The application connect to firebase and ask for token, than the application send this token in every API call to the server, and the server validates the token.
Now if we want to expose some of our endpoints and supply api access (e.g users will be able to login without browser), how should we do the authentication?
The users will send username and password, and we will need to authenticate against firebase with the credentials.
Is there best practice or guideline to how to approach this?
I want to still leverage firebase security features that I don't need to manage by myself (for example, preventing brute-force attacks), but not using the browser.
Related
I am using firebase firestore as datastore for my web based application. The application has 2 different actors.
Supervisor: logs in via a common password set for all supervisors plus the ability to generate unique codes.
User: logs in via the unique code generated by the supervisor.
I am using cloud functions to do the heavy lifting for both actors. Now these functions are protected with cors and whitelist for origins.
I am trying to secure the routes created with cloud functions with a Auth Middleware relying on the concept of if the request is not from authenticated account or not.
I have created a email and password accounts for both actors for the frontend section of my application.
The question is if I am to go with firebase Auth api to get the refresh token and use it as jwt in the Middleware, will it be an issue since let's say 100 supervisor are connected and performing some tasks, and the same thing for the second actor ? Because after examining the refresh token it contains the uid of the account authenticated and using the same account for multiple connection is the blocking stone in this scenario.
the point of a token to be used in every operation is to validate the origin of the request
Firebase Authentication uses ID tokens to verify the user's identity, not the origin of requests. A malicious user in your scenario can get the credentials from the app, and use them in their own code - calling APIs on your Firebase project.
If you want to only allow calls from your own app, consider using the new App Check feature of Firebase.
I am trying Firebase to authenticate users for a website that was initially built on Flask (using the flask login workflow with a postgres DB). However, I am not sure that I have a correct understanding of what would be considered best practices when using Firebase.
I read through this article, which I think has led me down a suboptimal path when it comes to actually managing users.
My questions are:
Should all the Firebase authentication be handled in the javascript?
If so, should I use the request.headers on the backend to verify the identity of the user?
Any tutorials (aside from the Firenotes one, which I am working through) much appreciated.
Should all the Firebase authentication be handled in the javascript?
No, it doesn't have to be JavaScript. But in general, you'll find that most apps using one of the existing Firebase Authentication providers handle the sign-in of the user in their client-side code, with calls to the authentication server.
If so, should I use the request.headers on the backend to verify the identity of the user?
When calling REST APIs Firebase itself passes the ID token of the authenticated user in the Authorization header, so that's a valid approach indeed. On the server you can then verify that the ID token is valid, and decide what data this user has access to.
I'm trying to build an IFTTT service and connect it to my Firebase backend.
I need to authenticate user as indicated in the IFTTT docs:
https://platform.ifttt.com/docs/api_reference#service-authentication
IFTTT’s protocol supports OAuth2 authentication, including support for
refresh tokens if so desired.
Your service API should use access tokens for authentication and as a
source of identity. A single access token should correspond to a
single user account or resource owner on your service.
If refresh tokens are used, they must be non-expiring. If refresh
tokens are not used, access tokens must be non-expiring.
But I can only get short-lived access tokens from Firebase it seems. Where can I get or how can I generate such tokens from the Firebase auth SDK?
Update in response to #FrankvanPuffelen:
I'll create an IFTTT service running on a Node server (possibly simply Cloud Functions) that will use the Firebase RTDB to send formatted HTTP request back to IFTTT. IFTTT requires me to authorize user accounts. Their required UX is something like this:
If an IFTTT user tries to use my service on the IFTTT website,
an auth dialog for my service pops up.
The user logs in and confirms IFTTT's access to their data on my service.
Some OAuth 2.0 tokens are exchanged.
IFTTT servers will periodically send requests (authentified with those tokens) on behalf of the user to my server.
Part of the question is: Can I use the Firebase Auth API to get those tokens, etc. or do I need to create a new OAuth 2.0 "layer" with my own generated tokens for IFTTT?
PS: I'm very new to OAuth, so it's all a bit confusing to me, sorry if the question isn't very clear.
So IFTTT calls Cloud Functions, which then calls Realtime Database, and you want to authentication the IFTT user with Realtime Database. Is that correct? If so, you can either use an OAuth2 token or create a Firebase Authentication session cookie.
Use an OAuth2 token
I did this not too long ago for accessing the Realtime Database from Google Apps Script. The requirements are relatively simple (once you know them):
The OAuth2 tokens must be requested with the correct scopes: https://www.googleapis.com/auth/userinfo.email and https://www.googleapis.com/auth/firebase.database.
The OAuth2 access token must be present in the request to Realtime Database.
The authenticated user must be at least an editor on the Firebase project. Note that this is not a Firebase Authentication user, but a Google user account.
Also see:
How to integrate Firebase into Google Apps Script without using (deprecated) database secret
Use a Firebase Authentication session cookie
You can also use a Firebase Authentication session cookie, which can be longer-lived (up to 2 weeks) than a regular Firebase Authentication ID token (up to an hour). You'll want to set up a Cloud Function for creating the session cookie, call that from IFTTT, and then pass the session cookie with the IFTTT request and along to the Realtime Database.
For more on this, see:
the Firebase documentation on managing session cookies.
I'm posting my solution here, this is a rough draft of what I did at at the time.
I'm using this auth method: My API has users with non-expiring OAuth2 access tokens and have an Express server responding at a Firebase HTTPS Cloud Function endpoint. Currently, at the prototyping stage, it generates fake tokens from the UID that are successfully accepted by IFTTT.
It's a redirect-heavy authentification flow based on this old IFTTT api example: https://github.com/IFTTT/connect_with_ifttt_auth_sample
Here's the gist of it:
Tokens and Auth Codes are just randomized and encrypted UIDs for now.
/oauth/authorize redirects to my app.
The app asks the user if they want to authorize IFTTT
The app redirects to /oauth/authorize_user
/oauth/authorize_user generates a user-specific code and redirects the user to IFTTT with this code
IFTTT asks /oauth/token to exchange the code for a Bearer tokens.
IFTTT can now make requests on behalf of this user with this bearer token.
Sample code here: https://gist.github.com/nathanvogel/15ed311258b91d7ec3d25f44047780e2
I'm creating an app that will run on the Google Assistant which should use firebase authentication to authenticate the user and then perform some user specific stuff.
It isn't currently possible for a user's Assistant account to automatically be linked to a Firebase Authentication account. You can create a basic OAuth2 server that uses Firebase Authentication to identify them as part of the Assistant Account Linking procedure, but this isn't done automatically. Once they have done the account linking, your Action will get an auth token (that your OAuth2 server has issued) and can use this to get a valid token to work with Firebase on their behalf.
Google doesn't typically announce future plans, however there have been a number of requests for similar features.
I'm following the guide and example provided by Microsoft here and I'm able to get the demo working, with the authentication happening in a console app, then making a request to a Web API with the correct token.
I'm looking to use this but the code in the console app would need to move to a Web App. Essentially: external server tries to access secure Web API, providing Azure AD username/password in the Authentication header of a HTTPS request. I pick up these credentials in the first insecure Web API, and attempt to authenticate the credentials against AD, obtaining the token. From here, I would then call the [Authorize]-protected Web API by making a request with the AD token.
At this point I'm using the same code from the example linked above, simply moving the code in the Console app up into the first insecure Web API controller, but I'm having no luck. I read on CloudIdentity that "You can only use those flows from a native client. A confidential client, such as a web site, cannot use direct user credentials.". Is this true? If so, is there another way to achieve my aim? I need to use the credentials as it may be likely that more services would use the API in the future, so each of these would need their own credentials to use that could be managed within Azure.
EDIT: In reading more around this, should I actually be aiming to use Client authentication, creating an "Application" within the Azure AD, and providing the client ID to each external service looking to call the API, to then authenticate with that, rather than credentials?
Yes, your edit is correct. The Resource Owner Password Credentials grant is meant to authenticate users, not applications. Typical use would be from an application that prompts you for username and password and then retrieves a token from Azure AD.
You can use the Client Credentials grant to get a token from Azure AD from a confidential client to call an API without user context. This flow requires that you register the application in Azure AD and generate a key (which will be used as the client secret). You can then use the ADAL library to ge a token from AAD as shown here.