I developed a flutter app,
I use Firebase as my DB, which means that any user can write and read from my DB,
I'm getting the following email every couple of hours.
[Firebase] Your Cloud Firestore database has insecure rules
We've detected the following issue(s) with your security rules:
any user can read your entire database
any user can write to your entire database
Which is exactly what I want, since I want my app to be available to unregistered users.
Did I missed something? is my app is actually insecure?
The access to the DB is done through the app with filters only user specific data.
Is there a way to make my more secure, and keeping it available for unregistered users?
I also not sure why allowing only registered user will make it insecure, since any one can register to the app with a click of a button.
Please shed some light on this issue.
You will definitely need to learn how to use security rules. A full discussion is beyond the scope of a single answer, but you should know that security rules allow you to specify who (signed in through Firebase Auth) can read and write which documents and collections. Not using security rules at all is a massive security hole.
The video in the following documentation explain it in a very simple way
https://firebase.google.com/docs/firestore/security/get-started#writing_rules
The bottom line is that you must auth your users, and then use security rules for filtering the data, inorder for your data to be secured.
Using insecure rule should be done only for testing s
Related
I think from searching the web this is not technically possible but I want to ask again in case I'm missing something.
I have an app that uses Firebase. Reading and writing is locked down through security rules for authorised users only but there's certain information I want unauthorised users to be able to access (so I don't have to put a login wall in front of them, influencing churn).
What I want to know is, is there any way of locking down this read access that only my app can call the DB? I know I can lock down domains to prevent someone writing localhost scrapers but what's to stop someone cloning and re-skinning an app and pointing it to the same back end? Is it possible to achieve this using your certificates fingerprint?
There is no way to limit access to your database to just your app. That just doesn't match with the cloud-based nature of the Firebase APIs. Anyone that knows the URL of your database can in in principle access it, and security rule are the way to ensure all access is authorized.
Note that security rules are not an all-or-nothing approach: you can require sign-in for some parts of your database, while leaving other parts publicly readable. But you can't make the publicly readable parts only be readable by your own app.
Some previous questions on the same topic:
how to make sure only my own website (clientside code) can talk to Firebase backend? (pretty much my go-to answer for this)
How to allow only my app to access firebase without a login?
Restrict Firebase database access to one Android app
How to allow only my app to access firebase without a login?
Update: since May 2021 you can actually restrict access to just users of your App by implementing Firebase App Check.
I have found a solution that maybe helps you or anyone that have a similar question. I answered it in this question:
Restricting Cloud Firestore to a specific domain
I think from searching the web this is not technically possible but I want to ask again in case I'm missing something.
I have an app that uses Firebase. Reading and writing is locked down through security rules for authorised users only but there's certain information I want unauthorised users to be able to access (so I don't have to put a login wall in front of them, influencing churn).
What I want to know is, is there any way of locking down this read access that only my app can call the DB? I know I can lock down domains to prevent someone writing localhost scrapers but what's to stop someone cloning and re-skinning an app and pointing it to the same back end? Is it possible to achieve this using your certificates fingerprint?
There is no way to limit access to your database to just your app. That just doesn't match with the cloud-based nature of the Firebase APIs. Anyone that knows the URL of your database can in in principle access it, and security rule are the way to ensure all access is authorized.
Note that security rules are not an all-or-nothing approach: you can require sign-in for some parts of your database, while leaving other parts publicly readable. But you can't make the publicly readable parts only be readable by your own app.
Some previous questions on the same topic:
how to make sure only my own website (clientside code) can talk to Firebase backend? (pretty much my go-to answer for this)
How to allow only my app to access firebase without a login?
Restrict Firebase database access to one Android app
How to allow only my app to access firebase without a login?
Update: since May 2021 you can actually restrict access to just users of your App by implementing Firebase App Check.
I have found a solution that maybe helps you or anyone that have a similar question. I answered it in this question:
Restricting Cloud Firestore to a specific domain
My android wallpaper app is connected to Firebase Cloud Firestore. It doesn't have any user authentication because I want the user to be able to use it without fuss. To do this, it must be in open access, meaning, the user is allowed to read and write. This is dangerous as he can also edit and modify the data if he knows the project id. The project id is visible in the url of the app so this is not really a good choice. Closed access is also not an option for obvious reasons.
Is there anything I can do to protect my data without need of a user authentication? I would love to see the code needed for the Cloud Firestore and Storage to protect the data. I want the user to read only and I, as the owner, should be the only one who could write. Please refer to the images attached. Thanks a lot for taking time to answer my questions.
My data structure in Firebase Cloud Firestore:
Securing your data with Security Rules
Firebase Cloud Firestore, Firebase Realtime Database and Firebase Cloud Storage are secured by their own Security Rules. They provide access control and data validation in a simple yet expressive format and allow you to control access to documents and collections in your database.
To build user-based and role-based access systems that keep your users' data safe, you need to use Firebase Authentication with Cloud Firestore Security Rules.
Your specific use case
I assume that you store your data in Firebase Cloud Firestore and the wallpapers in Firebase Cloud Storage. The user then gets a document with a link to download a wallpaper and maybe also can upload their own wallpapers to the database.
The dangers of an open database
As you mentioned allowing all reads and writes to your database in a production app is very dangerous. Obviously, anyone with your database reference will be able to read or write data to your database. Unauthorized users could destroy your backend and there are also possibilities that costs could increase exponentially. Therefore this is not recommended. There always should be some mechanisms preventing these scenarios.
Recommendation: Using anonymous authentication first and connect later with existing Identity Providers
I recommend that you use Firebase Authentication to create and use temporary anonymous accounts to authenticate with Firebase. These temporary anonymous accounts can be used to allow users who haven't yet signed up to your app to work with data protected by security rules while not being in the way of your user experience. If an anonymous user later decides to sign up to your app, you can link their sign-in credentials to the anonymous account so that they can continue to work with their protected data in future sessions.
You could also enable Google-Sign-In, Facebook Login, Twitter, GitHub, Microsoft, Yahoo, etc. to let users authenticate in a very fast and easy way without compromising on a security standpoint if using regular password authentication is not what you want (from a UX standpoint). FirebaseUI makes it really easy to add these to your existing app. Check out the official documentation on this topic.
Implementing Cloud Firestore Security Rules
The official documentation on this is really great on how to get started with Cloud Firestore Security Rules.
However these security rules could work for you:
Allow read access to all users to the root (Not recommended because this can create huge costs in production). Users don't have write (create, update, delete) access. In this case you can edit your data via the Firebase Console. Choose either option 1 or option 2 for your project.
rules_version = '2';
service cloud.firestore {
match /databases/{database}/documents {
// Option 1: Matches any document in the 'root' collection.
match /root/{rumiXYZ} {
allow read: if true;
allow write: if false;
}
// Option 2: Matches any document in the 'root' collection or subcollections.
match /root/{document=**} {
allow read: if true;
allow write: if false;
}
}
}
The {document=**} path in the rules above can be used to match any document in the collection/subcollections or in the entire database. This should however not be necessary for your use case. Continue on to the guide for structuring security rules to learn how to match specific data paths and work with hierarchical data.
Don't forget to secure your Firebase Cloud Storage too!
I think from searching the web this is not technically possible but I want to ask again in case I'm missing something.
I have an app that uses Firebase. Reading and writing is locked down through security rules for authorised users only but there's certain information I want unauthorised users to be able to access (so I don't have to put a login wall in front of them, influencing churn).
What I want to know is, is there any way of locking down this read access that only my app can call the DB? I know I can lock down domains to prevent someone writing localhost scrapers but what's to stop someone cloning and re-skinning an app and pointing it to the same back end? Is it possible to achieve this using your certificates fingerprint?
There is no way to limit access to your database to just your app. That just doesn't match with the cloud-based nature of the Firebase APIs. Anyone that knows the URL of your database can in in principle access it, and security rule are the way to ensure all access is authorized.
Note that security rules are not an all-or-nothing approach: you can require sign-in for some parts of your database, while leaving other parts publicly readable. But you can't make the publicly readable parts only be readable by your own app.
Some previous questions on the same topic:
how to make sure only my own website (clientside code) can talk to Firebase backend? (pretty much my go-to answer for this)
How to allow only my app to access firebase without a login?
Restrict Firebase database access to one Android app
How to allow only my app to access firebase without a login?
Update: since May 2021 you can actually restrict access to just users of your App by implementing Firebase App Check.
I have found a solution that maybe helps you or anyone that have a similar question. I answered it in this question:
Restricting Cloud Firestore to a specific domain
Can somebody else get the Firebase credentials from my APK and use them? Is this prevented by adding the SHA-1 keys for Android?
If it is prevented, what do I need security rules for since only code from my app with my SHA-1 can manipulate database at all?
If it is not prevented, can somebody else use my Firebase database as long as his requests fit the security rules? (Write 2nd client, which actually cannot do bad things but should not be allowed at all.)
Im not sure how I should think about security rules:
A) Protecting data against access and manipulation from bad guys + B?
B) Just a set of rules to keep data in a certain state and prevent my software from doing invalid database request?
A Firebase Database can be accessed via the REST API, or any of the client libraries. The decision about whether a client can or can't do something is entirely based on the rules.
You can even just access the Database URL in a web browser and see a JSON response by putting .json on the end, e.g. https://[YOUR_PROJECT_ID].firebaseio.com/.json
So the answer is definitely B! The default rules in a new Firebase project are that read and write to the database require auth, but you can configure them to provide whatever levels of protection you need.
Take a look at the Database Rules quickstart to see what you can do!
We don't ship the Realtime Database secret (or any other "secret" material) in the json file that gets baked into your app. That file simply contains resource identifiers that allow us to know which resources (database, storage bucket, analytics, etc.) to properly authenticate to (we use Firebase Authentication for these purposes), and we handle server side authorization to ensure that users are properly logged in.
If you are authorizing your requests properly (using Firebase Realtime Database Rules, for instance), your data is secure!
I'd recommend watching The Key to Firebase Security, one of our I/O talks, which talks in greater detail about how this works.
firebaser here
Thanks to the new feature called Firebase App Check, it is now actually possible to limit calls to your Realtime Database to only those coming from iOS, Android and Web apps that are registered in your Firebase project.
You'll typically want to combine this with the user authentication based security that Mike and Ian describe in their answers, so that you have another shield against abusive users that do use your app.