Firebase authenticaiton error handling in unity - firebase

Question

I have been struggling to find a solution for this and it seems that i'm doing something in the wrong way due to my limited knowladge, so here is the breakdown of the problem:
public void RegisterNewUser()
{
FetchRegisterInputValues();
if (CheckRegisterDataIntegrity())
{
_auth.CreateUserWithEmailAndPasswordAsync(_email, _password).ContinueWith(task => {
if (task.IsCanceled) {
Debug.LogError("CreateUserWithEmailAndPasswordAsync was canceled.");
return;
}
if (task.IsFaulted)
{
HandleRegistrationErrors(task.Exception);
return;
}
// Firebase user has been created.
Firebase.Auth.FirebaseUser newUser = task.Result;
Debug.LogFormat("Firebase user created successfully: {0} ({1})",
newUser.DisplayName, newUser.UserId);
});
}
else if (!CheckRegisterDataIntegrity())
{
HandleRegistrationErrors(new AggregateException("passwords do not match"));
}
}
above is the Registration function that I got straight from Firebase docs, it's very straightforward
the FetchRegisterInputValues(); function gets the email and passwords, the CheckRegisterDataIntegrity() compares the password with the password conformation in the form, and finally HandleRegistrationErrors(task.Exception); is meant to fire a popup panel to show the error,
this is how HandleRegistrationErrors(task.Exception); looks
private void HandleRegistrationErrors(AggregateException errMsg)
{
print("its here from the errors method " + errMsg.Message);
registerErrorPopup.OpenNotification();
registerErrorPopup.description = errMsg.Message;
}
it's using a UI asset from the asset store, the .OpenNotification(); starts the animation and pops it up, and then im just showing the message.
Now, I got two problems, the first is when there is an error encountered by Firebase and the if (task.IsFaulted) Condition is true, the HandleRegistrationErrors function should be called, right?. well that's exactly what happens, except only the print("it's here from the errors method " + errMsg.Message); line gets called and the rest of the function does not execute, I thought at first that its a problem with asset, but I tried doing it manually (created a native UI with unity and used SetActive() method to start the popUp), but again only print method executed, I think its because of the
CreateUserWithEmailAndPasswordAsync is Asynchronous and I should handle errors accordingly, but I really don't know how to go about it and there is no documentation that I could find.
The second problem is how to get the correct Error Message because of the task.Exception.Message always returns me a "One or more errors occurred". while the task.Exception itself gives the right message but it's not formatted correctly.

Answer 1

The first question is the easiest. To update your code with the minimal amount of effort, just replace ContinueWith with ContinueWithOnMainThread will force logic onto the main thread. Also, you should avoid calling task.Result if task.Exception is non-null as it will just raise the exception (see the related documentation).
For the threading related stuff: I go into much more detail about threading with Firebase and Unity here and you can read about the ContinueWithOnMainThread extension here.
For your second issue, the issue you're running into is that task.Exception is an AggregateException. I typically just attach a debugger and inspect this when debugging (or let Crashlytics analyze it in the field), and my UI state is only concerned about success or failure. If you want to inspect the error, the documentation I linked for AggregateException recommends doing something like:
task.Exception.Handle((e) => Debug.LogError($"Failed because {e}"));
Although I would play with .Flatten() or .GetBaseException() to see if those are easier to deal with.
I hope this helps!
--Patrick