QML and QGraphicsScene [duplicate] - qt

Question

I am using Qt5 beta and trying to embed a QWidget-based object into QML. The goal is to use QML as much as possible, and only use QWidget objects where QML does not do what I need. I found a link explaining how to do this for Qt4.7, but I have not found any information explaining how to do this in Qt5.
http://doc.qt.digia.com/4.7/declarative-cppextensions-qwidgets.html
The same example is also available in the Qt5 examples folder under:
examples\qtquick1\declarative\cppextensions\qwidgets
Unfortunately, this example uses QtQuick 1, rather than QtQuick 2, and I would like to use the new features of Qt5. I actually want to embed a qwt widget, but as a first step I would be happy to embed any simple QWidget-based object.
Can anybody help me get the example working under Qt5 / QtQuick 2 ?

Answer 1

Qt Quick 2 uses a scene graph for efficient rendering on the GPU. Unfortunately this makes it impossible to embed classic widgets into the scene. The old approach to embed such widgets with the help of QGraphicsProxyWidget works only with Qt Quick 1, because internally it uses a QGraphicsView for all the heavy lifting and QGraphicsProxyWidget is meant to be used with it.
As of now there are no plans to enable embedding classic QWidgets into the scene graph I know of. I think this is rather unlikely to change, because the concepts of QPainter, the painting framework used for the classic widgets, and the new scene graph doesn't play well with each other.
There some efforts to develop new widgets sets specifically tailored for the needs of QML, but none of them are as powerful and mature as the classic widgets. The most prominent ones are the QML Quick Controls, bundled with Qt since version 5.1.
If you really depend on QWT my advice would be to stick with Qt Quick 1.1 for now. It's still bundled with Qt 5, probably for cases like yours. That way you won't take advantage of the new scene graph, though.

Answer 2

You can embed QWidget to QML by using QQuickPaintedItem class:
http://doc.qt.io/qt-5/qquickpainteditem.html
Qt5 has an example:
http://doc.qt.io/qt-5/qtquick-customitems-painteditem-example.html
You should implement an inherent of QQuickPaintedItem with private widget attribute, that you want to embed. Provide paint method, that just render the QtWidget and provide mouse and other event transmitting from inherit of QQuickPaintedItem to embed QtWidget.
There's also QSG (Qt scene graph API), but my experience with that thing wasn't smooth. I believe the clue in multithreading (performing rendering in the different thread (not the Qt GUI thread one, however on Windows that's not true and all is done in main GUI thread).
I've implemented embedding of QCustomPlot, here's link: github.com/mosolovsa/qmlplot

Answer 3

What could be done is to render the widget to an image and upload as texture.For interaction someone needs to forward events like mouseClick or keyPressed from the sceneGraph, translate to widget coordinates, pass on, render and upload texture again. Just an idea :)

Answer 4

The recommended approach is to stay with a QWidget based application and embed the QML parts using QWidget::createWindowContainer.

Answer 5

Further to Julien's answer - a simple way to achieve this is to use QQuickWidget to display the QML scene, and then add a regular QWidget as a child of the QQuickWidget. You can also add a simple intermediate QObject to anchor the QWidget to an item in the scene.
E.g.:
In main.qml:
Item {
... // layouts, extra items, what have you
Item
{
objectName: "layoutItem"
anchors.fill: parent
}
... // more layouts, extra items, etc.
}
widgetanchor.h:
class WidgetAnchor: public QObject
{
ptr<QWidget> _pWidget;
QPointer<QQuickItem> _pQuickItem;
public:
WidgetAnchor(QWidget* pWidget, QQuickItem* pItem)
: QObject(pWidget), _pWidget(pWidget), _pQuickItem(pItem)
{
connect(_pQuickItem, &QQuickItem::xChanged, this, &WidgetAnchor::updateGeometry);
connect(_pQuickItem, &QQuickItem::yChanged, this, &WidgetAnchor::updateGeometry);
connect(_pQuickItem, &QQuickItem::widthChanged, this, &WidgetAnchor::updateGeometry);
connect(_pQuickItem, &QQuickItem::heightChanged, this, &WidgetAnchor::updateGeometry);
updateGeometry();
}
private:
void updateGeometry()
{
if (_pQuickItem)
{
QRectF r = _pQuickItem->mapRectToItem(0, QRectF(_pQuickItem->x(), _pQuickItem->y(), _pQuickItem->width(), _pQuickItem->height()));
_pWidget->setGeometry(r.toRect());
}
}
};
In main.cpp:
int main(int argc, char *argv[])
{
QApplication app(argc, argv);
auto pqw = new QQuickWidget;
pqw->setSource(QUrl::fromLocalFile("main.qml"));
pqw->setResizeMode(QQuickWidget::SizeRootObjectToView);
pqw->setAttribute(Qt::WA_DeleteOnClose);
auto pOwt = new MyWidget(pqw);
if (auto pOverlayItem = pqw->rootObject()->findChild<QQuickItem*>("overlayItem"))
new WidgetAnchor(pOwt, pOverlayItem);
pqw->show();
return app.exec();
}
The documentation states that using QQuickWidget has advantages over QQuickView and QWidget::createWindowContainer, such as no restrictions on stacking order, but has a 'minor performance hit'.
Hope that helps.