I'm evaluating Flyway and want to know if it can check for the presence of any externally made changes? I.e. if someone makes a change directly to the database, outside of Flyway, can I catch that?
I tried validate and info but it doesn't seem to notice.
No, it can't. Flyway expects you to make all changes to what you want it to manage (structure, reference data, ...) via Flyway.
Here at Redgate we support the concept of a schema snapshot. If you use either SQL Server or Oracle (as these are the database we have best support for) then you can take a snapshot after deployment and later compare this artifact with target database the next time you deploy to make sure that it hasn't "drifted". Our tools can also output a candidate Flyway migration script that will ensure Flyway is consistent with the actual target. If you're interested in this approach I can send you sample scripts of how this is achieved. But remember, this only works with Oracle and SQL Server.
Related
We have a production system with a large DB (several hundred tables) and would like to begin using Flyway to manage DDL changes that occur through the dev cycle. However, the organization is setup in such a way that there are production DB changes that sometimes occur, mostly just data changes but possibly DDL, that will happen outside of a data migration tool. While this is obviously an organizational challenge, does this fact alone cripple a tool like Flyway? Or is there a workflow where Flyway could rebuild its indices on demand such that any out-of-band DB change like this is pulled in?
We'd love to use Flyway, but would need to integrate it incrementally until all teams using the system are trained/bought in.
When introducing Flyway to a DB with existing data you will need to baseline Flyway to integrate with your existing data. See baseline.
For changes made after this, Flyway will only track and version changes made from its own migration scripts and not changes made externally to it. However, this does not mean you cannot use the two together, but you would need to be more aware of your database structure to avoid conflicts between your flyway migrations and external changes.
Transactional data changes made to production shouldn't impact Flyway as these won't be versioned.
If you're referring to static data (eg lookup data) that you'd like Flyway to manage, then this isn't detected by Flyway (at least not today). If you discover that you have drift you'll need to add the changes as a new migration script using idempotent syntax to ensure that next time this runs against production it doesn't try to make the same changes again.
For out-of-band schema changes, The enterprise edition of Flyway has a drift check, so at least you'd be made aware of them. However, as for the data changes described above, you'll need to manually add these schema changes as an idempotent migration script.
I use flyway 8.5.0 and I want that my beforeMigrate or my afterMigrate sql is reported in the history table. Is this feaseable? or is there any config to setup this?
Then an other question: my repetable only runs when they change (checksum) but for my understanding the repetible sql should run every time. not so?
The beforeMigrate and afterMigrate SQL wont appear in your history table. If you look at the tutorial example for callbacks you can see that beforeMigrate can be called before the schema history table is created which would cause issues if it was trying to add itself to it. Additionally, I'm assuming these will be mostly static executions and would not really be part of the version history.
https://flywaydb.org/documentation/tutorials/callbacks
For repeatable, no they are only applied when the checksum has changed.
Repeatable migrations are very useful for managing database objects whose definition can then simply be maintained in a single file in version control. Instead of being run just once, they are (re-)applied every time their checksum changes.
https://flywaydb.org/documentation/tutorials/repeatable
We have not used Flyway from the beginning of our project. We are at an advanced state of development. An expert review has suggested to use Flyway in our project.
The problem is that we have moved part of our services (microservices) into another testing environment as well.
What is the best way to properly implement Flyway? The requirements are:
In Development environment, no need to alter the schema which is already existing. But all new scripts should be done using Flyway.
In Testing environment, no need to alter the schema which is already existing. But what is not available in testing environment should be created automatically using Flyway when we do migrate project from Dev to test.
When we do migration to a totally new envrionment (UAT, Production etc) the entire schema should be created automatically using Flyway.
From the documentation, what I understood is:
Take a backup of the development schema (both DDL and DML) as SQL script files, give a file name like V1_0_1__initial.sql.
Clean the development database using "flyway clean".
Baseline the Development database "flyway baseline -baselineversion=1.0.0"
Now, execute "flyway migrate" which will apply the SQL script file V1_0_1__initial.sql.
Any new scripts should be written with higher version numbers (like V2_0_1__account_table.sql)
Is this the correct way or is there any better way to do this?
The problem is that I have a test database where we have different set of data (Data in Dev and test are different and I would like to keep the data as it is in both the environments). If so, is it good to separate the DDL and DML in different script files when we take it from the Dev environment and apply them separately in each environment? The DML can be added manually as required; but bit confused if I am doing the right thing.
Thanks in advance.
So, there are actually two questions here. Data management and Flyway management.
In terms of data management, yes, that should be a separate thing. Data grows and grows. Trying to manage data, beyond simple lookup tables, from source control quickly becomes very problematic. Not to mention that you want different data in different environments. This also makes automating deployments much more difficult (branching would be your friend if you insist on going this route, one branch for each data set, then deploy appropriately).
You can implement Flyway on an existing project, yes. The key is establishing the baseline. You don't have to do all the steps you outlined above. Let's say you have an existing database. You have to get the script that defines that database. That single script should include all appropriate DDL (and, if you want, DML). Name it following the Flyway standards. Something like V1.0__Baseline.sql.
With that in place, all you must do is run:
flyway baseline
That will establish your existing code base as the start point. From there, you just have to create scripts following the naming standard: V1.1xxx V2.0xxx V53000.1xxx. And run
flyway migrate
To deploy appropriate changes.
The only caveat to this is that, as the documentation states, you must ensure that all your databases match this V1.0 that you're creating and marking as the baseline. Any deviation will cause errors as you introduce new changes and migrate them into place. As long as you've got matching baseline points, you should be able to proceed with different data in different environments with no issues.
This is my how-to instruction on integration flyway with prod DB: https://delicious-snipe-938.notion.site/How-to-integrate-Flyway-with-existing-MySQL-DB-in-Prod-PostgreSQL-is-similar-1eabafa8a0e844e88205c2f32513bbbe.
I have delivered a Product to the customer. Now I have upgraded the Product, which includes changes to the database.
Customer wants to upgrade the Product. Now will Flyway help in the migration of Customer data from older version to newer version. Please let me know, if this is a valid use case. The flyway documentation talks about its use during development only.
Flyway allows you to change your database by running a set of scripts in a defined order. These scripts are called 'migrations' as they allow you to 'migrate' your database from one version to another.
The idea is you can start with an an empty database and each migration script will successively bring that database up from empty up to the current version. However, it's also possible to start with an existing database by creating a 'baseline' migration.
As SudhirR said, Flyway's primary use case is to define schema changes. However, it's perfectly possible to change data also. Since Flyway is just running plain SQL, in principle almost anything you can do in a SQL script you can also do in a Flyway migration.
In the case you described it should be possible to use Flyway to migrate the customer database. The steps you could take are:
Generate a sql script that includes the entire DDL (including indexes, triggers, procedures, ...) of the production database. To do this you will need to add insert statements for all the reference data present in the database.
Save this script in your Flyway project as something like 'V1__base_version.sql'
Run the flyway baseline command against your production database
This will set up your production database for use with Flyway
Add a new migration script to migrate your customer's data to the new version
e.g. create new table, copy data from old table to new table, delete old table
Run flyway migrate to upgrade production
These steps are adapted from the Flyway documentation page here.
Of course you should read the Flyway docs and manually test on a throwaway DB before you run anything against production. However I think in principle Flyway could be a good fit for your use case.
Flyway should be used for schema migrations and any reference data (basic data that is required by the system/application in order to function properly).
Putting client specific data migrations would not be a use case. However, if you can represent the data migration "generically" by not using IDs and instead use names or types than it could be a candidate. Meaning if you could write a migration in a way that could be applied to all clients, then that would be the use case to put it in as a flyway migration.
Otherwise data migrations would be applied in some other way outside of the process like requesting special access to the database or having some team that manages the database to apply the scripts.
If you are doing custom data modifications quite often then I'd say something is wrong in some other area of the SDLC and you may need to increase testing so that bugs don't mess up the data in the first place.
I looked at the Flyway samples and documentation and tried to understand if it is useful in my environment.
The following conceptual detail is unclear to me: How does Flyway manage the changes between database versions? It obviously does NOT compare database life-instances (see answer here:Can Flyway find out and generate migration files from datamodel?)
In detail my setup looks like this:
I create SQL create and insert scripts when coding (automatically and manually). This means every version of my database is represented by a number of insert/create statements.
In my world I execute these scripts through a database tool (sqlplus from Oracle). Each run would setup the database _from_scratch_ (!).
Can I put these very same scripts 1 to 1 inside the "migration" path of Flyway? What happens if the target database is way older than the last "migration step" I did (or flyway did not yet exist when it was installed)?
Update:
I got some input from another Flyway user:
It seems like each "migration" (version of the database) has to be hand-written SQL/Java code and contains only "updates" from the previous "migration" of database.
If this is true, I wonder how this can be used with traditional coding technics: in my world SQL statements are generated automatically and contain all database init/create statements, not just "updates" to some previous version. If my SQL code generator could do that, then I wouldn't even need a tool like Flyway :-).
Your question about "how to handle a DB that has a longer history than there are migration scripts?" You need to create a V1_ migration/sql script that matches/recreates your latest DB schema. Something that can take a blank DB to what you have today. Create/generate that sql script using your existing DB tools and then put it in flyways migration directory. (And test V1 by using flyway against a clean DB and see if you get what you expect.) http://flywaydb.org/documentation/existing.html
After that point in time, all later versions must be added in as you work. When you decide you need a new table, in your dev environment, write a new V*_.sql that modifies your schema to the way you need it.
This blog goes over this situation for a Spring/SQL application. https://blog.synyx.de/2012/10/database-migration-using-flyway-and-spring-and-existing-data/