I know that we can use a Firebase backend function to send an HTTP request to Google Apps Script and receive it using "doGet()".
However, is it possible to call a Google Apps Script function from Firebase without sending an HTTP request (since it's part of the same Google account)?
My concern is with security, where one may be able to guess/sniff the right URL/parameters and then execute the Google Apps Script function (which makes a purchase). Alternatively, there may be a proper way to secure GAS web apps.
There are quite some details missing. But I think you're asking of a Google Cloud Functions/Cloud Functions for Firebase can call into an Apps Script web app or a Apps Script REST API. The answer is that they indeed can invoke those URLs (if they're publicly accessible and fall within your quota).
But that is no more security risk than that any browser can invoke these URLs. The security should not come from knowing or being able to call the URLs. If you want to secure an API, you should implement proper security on it. For more on see Authorization for Google Services in Apps SCript
Related
I need to implement a scenario where, after a file is uploaded to Google Cloud Storage, a function is triggered and processes the file. In this case, processing basically means sanitizing the file, storing it into Firestore and making it accessible via another HTTP-triggered function (a REST API of sorts).
Both user-facing ends of this process (a file upload and HTTP function) need to be secured. The process will be used in server-to-server scenario: one side is going to be a backend written in either Node.js or .NET, the other will be my Firebase solution (Cloud Storage and HTTP-triggered function as per above). In Firebase, I am going to maintain a custom set of users that should have access to the system - my idea was to use a simple system where each user will have a client id and a client secret (basically an oAuth client credentials grant type).
Based on what I read online, an only option to implement this is to use [Firebase auth with custom tokens][1]. I found lots of examples online on how to do that, but it was always about client-to-server scenarios (e.g. a Javascript web app talking to REST API). Server-to-server scenarios were not mentioned anywhere and indeed, I am unsure how to go about implementing it - I can call auth.createCustomToken(uid) just fine in my HTTP Firestore function, but there seem to be no server-side libraries I could use to call auth.SignInWithCustomTokenAsync(customToken).
To sum it up:
How can I use Firebase auth with custom tokens in server-to-server
scenario, where I need to sign in using a previously generated
custom token from a server environment?
If it is not possible,
what's the other alternative to securely implement the
above-described architecture?
I've contacted Google Support and if anyone else is struggling with this, in server-side scenarios, recommended approach is to call signInWithCustomToken endpoint in Firebase Auth REST API.
I have a Node.js API (built with Express.js) hosted on Firebase Cloud Functions and an accompanying web application hosted on Firebase Hosting which is supposed to interact with the aforementioned API.
I would like to restrict calls to the API so that only the web application would be able to call the cloud functions. How can I achieve that?
What I have tried:
using the App Check or more precisely Google's reCAPTCHA v3 for web apps. I have whitelisted the domain of the web application and have activated App Check token validation server side as well. The problem with App Check, however, is that I am able to obtain the reCAPTCHA attestation token from the browser (after authenticating through the web app) and use that with requests made from anywhere. This enables bombarding the API from outside the web application and defeats the purpose of using App Check in the first place.
Something to note here, the documentation for activating App Check in Cloud Functions instructs the usage of functions.https.onCall(). However, since my API is built using Express.js, I had to use a workaround to be able to use functions.https.onRequest() as instructed here.
restricting the Cloud Function from Google Cloud console to allow only clients of the same project to call the function as instructed here. Unfortunately, my web application hosted on Firebase Hosting does not seem to belong under the same Google Cloud project. Apps hosted on Firebase Hosting do not appear in Google Cloud console. Furthermore, after adjusting the Ingress settings of the functions to "allow internal traffic only", I am receiving CORS errors when attempting to access the API through the web application. I am unable to access the API from anywhere else though, which is partly the desired outcome.
Before anyone proposes limiting the domains in CORS options from within the API, while this might serve the purpose of restricting access to the API endpoints, it still would allow calling the function rapidly and thus, potentially, racking up the bill.
I am grateful for any suggestions!
Firebaser here.
This is a great question! Doug has already made some great points above, and I'll just add to that by saying that the TTL on App Check tokens reduce the replay window that you observed in your first bullet point, and this TTL is configurable.
The default TTL for reCAPTCHA v3 is 1 day to protect against running out of quota, but you can set a shorter TTL to increase the cost for an attacker trying to set up a replay attack. But please do be mindful of the associated trade-offs as described in the documentation. You can read about the associated quotas and limits here.
Unfortunately, web applications redirected from Firebase Hosting can't hook up to the GCP internal network. App Check is actually exactly what you are looking for in this situation.
Finally, because we are continuously working on improving the App Check platform, the comments you leave here are valuable for us as we decide on what anti-abuse features we want to work on next.
I have a simple web site hosted in Firebase and it is making AJAX calls to REST API endpoints in GCP Cloud Run.
I would like to limit these endpoints only to the calls coming from this site hosted in Firebase. Any call coming from any other origin should not be able to use the endpoints. What is the best way to do this?
When I was not using GCP Cloud Run, I was doing a host check on the API side to make sure that request is coming from my client but now with Cloud Run this is not possible. What else could be done?
Please note that the web-site hosted in Firebase is very simple and do not do any user authentication.
Challenge: Restrict access to a Cloud Run service to a single web application, without relying on:
Restricting access to the web application
Imposing authentication on users
This difficulty is not specific to Cloud Run. It's a general challenge for static sites backed by APIs, and a reason why many sites have authentication. As mentioned in the question comments, a server-side "host" check is not a meaningful security layer, as everything in the HTTP request can be faked. I strongly recommend you not worry about keeping your API private or add user authentication to keep the system simple and access accountable.
If that's not possible, you can still take the authentication approach by creating a single user, embedding the credentials in the site, and rotating them regularly (by redeploy to Firebase Hosting) to prevent credential theft from having indefinite access to your API. Having Firebase Auth in the middle is better than a simple API key because it prevents replay attacks from accessing your API.
I am building some internal API for my apps/website with Firebase Functions. Internal API as in to let my apps/website to process something on server side, its doesn't mean to open to public use.
My Apps is built with ionic and website is built with angular.
I noticed the one of Firebase Functions Pricing calculation include "Invocations". Is that Invocations means every time when I call the API equal to 1 Invocation? If yes, then the API might be abused by end user, since they able to view the website source and found the API.
I been searching solution in google, some of them suggest to enable authentication and cors, to avoid abuse of the usage. But authentication and cors still counting the Invocations right?
My code structure:
client call API by get/post method, pass user TOKEN that get from Firebase Authentication
request reach the Firebase Functions
server will check the preflight info by using CORS, as well as validate the TOKEN.
Return error if didn't pass on the (3), else proceed to execute the function.
So I assume if end user inspect my web source code and get the API URL, they can simply spam my API right? Then my bill will burst because of the load of Invocations.
If you suspect that your project is being abused, which is always possible, contact Firebase support to work towards a resolution.
I'm building a React+Redux app, and using some firebase cloud functions which I call in an action creator. I was wondering, if I should save the cloud function url as an environment variable, since this code is on the client side? I already have cors implemented to only allow requestsfrom my domain.
Thank you
In general, you should always make sure that endpoints that can be called from a client are robust enough to be secure if publicly disclosed. Browser, Android, and iOS apps can all be inspected and disassembled to discover outgoing request URLs.
"Security through obscurity" can buy you time, but is not in and of itself a real means of protecting your application. Instead, you should make sure that the endpoint requires sufficient authorization (e.g. by using the Firebase ID token as per this sample).
In other words, there's no need to hide it because at the end of the day, you can't!