I use the HTTP Web API to send Downstream messages over GCM (recently switch to FCM) as well as Mozilla push.
GCM and FCM got a push authorization key and I assume that Google can clearly identify me as the message sender.
FCM URL (https://fcm.googleapis.com/fcm/send)
The Mozilla push service seems to be anonymous since it does not require any authorization key.
Mozilla (https://updates.push.services.mozilla.com/wpush/v1/)
My implementation does work and push messages are send to Chrome, Firefox and Android.
However, I cannot find any usage Statistics. I looked into the Firebase console as well the Google cloud console. All counters remains zero.
Can I or should I be able to see the usage statics for the Google push service ? Is their something similar Mozilla ?
Thanks for looking into this.
Regards
Stefan
There is currently only one way to find the statistics/statuses of the messages sent through GCM/FCM.
From the Cloud Messaging section in the Firebase Console:
It would seem that the Impressions and Opens are still only available for messages sent using the console. But Sends for sure now counts the messages sent using the FCM API.
Reference: https://firebase.googleblog.com/2018/08/in-app-messaging-crashlytics.html
I haven't tried Mozilla Push Service before so I'm unable to comment on that one.
Related
Is it possible to identify whether a particular push notification message was delivered to a particular token via Firebase Cloud Messaging? And, if so, is it possible to do so via an API call or by listening to some callback?
I know that I can look at aggregate statistics in the console and even segment those statistics through analytics tags, but cannot find a way to get more discrete information.
I also know that the API will synchronously respond if a token is invalid but the process by which Apple and Google invalidate tokens is a bit opaque (to me) and doesn't help if someone simply turned off push notifications for my app.
Thanks!
Jason
If someone turned off push notification – you can check it with code
Swift ios check if remote push notifications are enabled in ios9 and ios10
Android app - detect if app push notification is off
But user can be offline, or APNs / Firebase service – can get some problems and your notification will be drop. You can check delivery status with some code in iOS and Android applications.
If you need check, delivery status for some push you can make push notification extension (in iOS). For send status about delivered notification in your API. More info about push notification extension.
https://developer.apple.com/documentation/usernotifications/unnotificationserviceextension
It can be helpful
https://developer.apple.com/documentation/usernotifications
https://developer.apple.com/documentation/usernotifications/modifying_content_in_newly_delivered_notifications
https://firebase.google.com/docs/cloud-messaging/understand-delivery
https://firebase.google.com/docs/cloud-messaging/android/receive#handling_messages About handling messages in Android (you can send status delivered too)
I hope this answer will help with your problem.
UPD:
https://firebase.google.com/docs/cloud-messaging/understand-delivery
Received (available only on Android devices) — The data message or
notification message has been received by the app. This data is
available when the receiving Android device has FCM SDK 18.0.1 or
higher installed.
On this page they explain Web Push with Service Workers stating
Chrome currently uses Firebase Cloud Messaging (FCM) as its push service. FCM recently adopted the Web Push protocol. and then explaining Firebase and so on...
Since the Service Worker gives me a unique endpoint and a pubkey, it seems to me that technically it should be possible to use that endpoint directly, without anything additionally - except if Google deliberally forces a registration.
I mean, just send a POST request to that endpoint, sending just the notification data encrypted/authenticated using the pubkey without any "VAPID".
Do I absolutely need a Firebase account or is it possible to access the endpoint directly (without additional registration) if I just want to send a notification to a single device?
It's 2021 and all major browsers implement a push service and support VAPID now. You use a web push library (Javascript, Python, C#,..) of choice.
There is no need to register anywhere.
The technical mechanism in short is this:
You generate two VAPID keys once using the push library. One key is private and one is public.
The public key is used in the javascript as "application server key" when subscribing to the push service of the browser.
If the subscription is successful you receive a subscription object from the browser containing an endpoint and two additional keys.
The endpoint is an address depending on the web browser / manufacturer and the service it is currently using. The endpoints look like (Oct 2021) e.g.
Google Chrome h_tt_ps://fcm.googleapis.com/fcm/send/cz9gl....., Microsoft Edge h_tt_ps://wns2-par02p.notify.windows.com/w/?toke....., Mozilla Firefox h_tt_ps://updates.push.services.mozilla.com/wpush/v2/gAAAAABhaUA....
If your server program has this information (endpoint and keys from subscription object) it can send a push message to the endpoint with the push library. The corresponding service in the web, hosted by the manufacturer sends this to the browser's service on the device.
There is the PushAPI which shall get used.
But it doesn't is supported by every Browser at the moment.
You can find nice examples in the Service Worker Cookbook of Mozilla
We use Firebase to send push notifications to both Android and iOS devices. We use Http (not XMPP).
How to get delivery reports for push notifications? We want to check if a push is delivered to devices (both Android and iOS).
I cannot see any stats or reports in Firebase console.
Please help.
As seen in the Possible Duplicate Post I linked, there is currently no available reports for FCM, other than what can be seen in the Firebase Console (if you sent the message using the console) and using the Diagnostics/Statistics tool in your Play Dev Console.
There is no API that retrieves these FCM log details as of the moment. However, there's been a recent improvement in the Firebase Notifications console where stats (sent count only for now) for messages sent using the FCM API is included in the Firebase Notification console stats. From my answer in the similar post:
As of August 2018, stats for messages sent using the FCM API are now visible from the console. From the Cloud Messaging section, click on the Reports tab. From there, you will be able to filter by message type (notification, data, and all)
It would seem that the Impressions and Opens are still only available for messages sent using the console. But Sends for sure now counts the messages sent using the FCM API.
Reference: https://firebase.googleblog.com/2018/08/in-app-messaging-crashlytics.html
Our findings: In order to view statistics for Data messages, the data messages will need to include an analytics label. Check to make sure that these are included. It is just a label, https://firebase.google.com/docs/cloud-messaging/understand-delivery#adding-analytics-labels-to-messages so even without the analytics label, the message should still be sent. It just won't be tracked by their reporting. Data messages do not automatically generate a notification though. Different app states and message types will have different message receiving behavior. A data message should be received in onMessage or setBackgroundMessageHandler for JavaScript clients. Try checking these callbacks to see if the message is received there. I'd highly recommend checking out the quickstart, which should be working fine. You can use it as a base to build off or reference to compare with your app to identify potential problem areas. So our understanding is that it needs to be handled properly on the mobile end, https://firebase.google.com/docs/cloud-messaging/js/receive (though this is the javascript client, it will still apply to mobile).
You can rather go to the Google cloud console to check messages sent.
Select period from available options on top right of the page.
https://console.cloud.google.com/apis/dashboard?folder=&organizationId=&project=[project-name]
The delivery report added to the FCM:
Received (available only on Android devices) — The data message or notification message has been received by the app. This data is available when the receiving Android device has FCM SDK 18.0.1 or higher installed.
https://firebase.google.com/docs/cloud-messaging/understand-delivery#message-delivery-reports
We are about to switch to Firebase notifiaction API from Parse.com (that are retiring their service in jan 2017) to send push notification to our android and iOS Apps.
My question now is that I can't see any statistics about counts of successful deliveries and opens in the Firebase Console for a specific message ? The only thing we get when posting to https://fcm.googleapis.com/fcm/send is a message_id
{"message_id":123456789}
But I havn't seen any documentation on a api how to follow up a sent message with this message_id. And the Firebase console has only the these kind of stats for messages created in the Console Gui, not the one create through an api post.
These stats was availible in Parse.com. But it seems as Firebase Cloud Messaging is a bit more low level, and perhaps these stats doesn't come out the box, so they might have to be custom made in a logging app etc by sending back events from the apps when messages as received and opened etc. Or is there a standardized way that I've missed when reading the Firebase Notification api docs ?
When you send notifications from the Firebase Notifications console, you get statistics about how many people received and opened the messages. But there is no API (yet) for Firebase Notifications.
If you're using the Firebase Cloud Messaging API (https://fcm.googleapis.com/fcm/send), the message statistics don't show up in the Firebase Notifications console. You can (as AL. says) get delivery statistics in the Google Play Developer Console in that case.
firebase allows you to view sent/delivered/opened statuses by default from their website
http://console.firebase.google.com
at the notification section
but I am not sure about the parse.com implementations
also if you are a new comer to firebase let it collect user data for about 24 hours after successfully migrating to firebase
I found that in the first day the notifications weren't really reporting immediately
I think you're looking for the FCM Diagnostics and Statistics feature.
However, this is not visible in the Firebase Console, only in your Google Play Developer Console. And the feature only works if your app is at least in Alpha Testing.
I'm having trouble figuring out whether or not FCM keeps logs of sent FCM push notifications, and if so, how to access them. I'm having intermittent issues with sending push notifications from an FCM server to an iphone app, and would love to be able to see at what stage the push is failing.
I found the below documentation that suggests that these logs should be kept somewhere:
https://support.google.com/googleplay/android-developer/answer/2663268?hl=en
("You can look up messages sent through Firebase Cloud Messaging with a registration token or message ID.")
However, I can't seem to figure out how to access them. Since my app is currently iOS only, I don't have an app in the Google Play Developer console, and my firebase console doesn't seem to contain any such logs. However, based on the possible message statuses in the documentation above (e.g. Accepted, sent to APNS), it seems like google / firebase should store message logs sent to iOS as well as to Android.
Thanks in advance for your help!