Looping a function over Lists in R - r

I have a list of samples, each of varying lengths. I need to compare sample means (using a Mann-Whitney-Wilcoxon test) for all samples in the list. Current code is as follows:
wilcox.v = list() ##This creates the list of samples
for (i in df){
treat = list(i$treatment)
wilcox.v = c(wilcox.v,treat)
}
###This *should* iterate over all items in the list
wilcox = sapply(wilcox.v, function(i){ wilcox.test(as.numeric(wilcox.v[i,]), as.numeric(wilcox.v[-i,]), exact = FALSE)$p.value
})
I'd like to have the function return a vector of p-values, so that the broader function can re-sample if necessary.
The problem seems to lie in the need to compare a sample mean to all other sample means in the list.
I'm sure there's an easy way to do this (and I think it has something to do with calling indicies correctly), but I'm not sure!

AS joran said, you wrote your apply function a little wonky. There are two ways you can fis this.
Modify it so i is in fact an index reference:
wilcox = sapply(1:length(wilcox.v)
,function(i){ wilcox.test(as.numeric(wilcox.v[[i]])
,as.numeric(wilcox.v[[-i]]), exact = FALSE)$p.value
})
modify your function so it appropriately treats i as a list element. I'll leave this as an exercise to you (primarily since I don't want to deal with the wilcox.v[-i,] term.

Thanks for your help! This is the solution I ended up using. It's hardly elegant but it gets the job done.
mannwhit = vector()
for (i in mannwhit.v){
for (j in mannwhit.v){
if (identical(i,j) == FALSE){
p.val = wilcox.test(i, j, paired=FALSE)$p.value
mannwhit = c(mannwhit, p.val)
}
}
}

Related

Generate Vectors With For Loop in R

Incredibly basic question. I'm brand new to R. I feel bad for asking, but also like someone will crush it:
I'm trying to generate a number of vectors with a for loop. Each with an unique name, numbered by iteration. The code I'm attaching throws an error, but I think it explains what I'm trying to do in principle fairly well.
Thanks in advance.
vectorBuilder <- function(num){
for (x in num){
paste0("vec",x) <- rnorm(10000, mean = 0, sd = 1)}
}
numSeries <- 1:10
vectorBuilder(numSeries)
You can write the function to return a named list :
create_vector <- function(n) {
setNames(replicate(n, rnorm(10000), simplify = FALSE),
paste0('vec', seq_len(n)))
}
and call it as :
data <- create_vector(10)
data will have list of length 10 with each element having a vector of size 10000. It is better to keep data in this list instead of creating lot of vectors in global environment. However, if you still want separate vectors you can use list2env :
list2env(data, .GlobalEnv)

Repeat codeline in R

How can I repeat a code-line in R?
I have created a function called 'func1' and I want ‘data’ to run though ‘func1’ 10 times after another
This is what I have now:
data<-func1(data);data<-func1(data);data<-func1(data);data<-func1(data);data<-func1(data);data<-func1(data)
data<-func1(data);data<-func1(data);data<-func1(data);data<-func1(data)
This is what I would like to have:
solution
data<-func1(data,times=10)
Thanks in advance
Jannik
A simple loop would do this,
for(i in 1:10) {
data <- func1(data)
}
You can write a higher-order function which, given a function, f, a seed value, s, and an integer n, computes
f(f(f( ....(s))...)
(with n function evalutions):
iterate <- function(f,s,n){
if(n == 0){
s
}
else{
f(iterate(f,s,n-1))
}
}
Then you seem to want data <- iterate(func1,data,10)
You can also write iterate using a loop (in a way which is similar to the excellent answer of #JamesElderfield ) but the recursive approach given above is fairly common in the functional programming paradigm (which is one of R's native paradigms).

How to extract a parameter from a list of functions in a loop

I have a large data set and I want to perform several functions at once and extract for each a parameter.
The test dataset:
testdf <- data.frame(vy = rnorm(60), vx = rnorm(60) , gvar = rep(c("a","b"), each=30))
I first definded a list of functions:
require(fBasics)
normfuns <- list(jarqueberaTest=jarqueberaTest, shapiroTest=shapiroTest, lillieTest=lillieTest)
Then a function to perform the tests by the grouping variable
mynormtest <- function(d) {
norm_test <- res_reg <- list()
for (i in c("a","b")){
res_reg[[i]] <- residuals(lm(vy~vx, data=d[d$gvar==i,]))
norm_test[[i]] <- lapply(normfuns, function(f) f(res_reg[[i]]))
}
return(norm_test)
}
mynormtest(testdf)
I obtain a list of test summaries for each grouping variable.
However, I am interested in getting only the parameter "STATISTIC" and I did not manage to find out how to extract it.
You can obtain the value stored as "STATISTIC" in the output of the various tests with
res_list <- mynormtest(testdf)
res_list$a$shapiroTest#test#statistic
res_list$a$jarqueberaTest#test#statistic
res_list$a$lillieTest#test#statistic
And correspondingly for set b:
res_list$b$shapiroTest#test$statistic
res_list$b$jarqueberaTest#test$statistic
res_listb$lillieTest#test$statistic
Hope this helps.
Concerning your function fgetparam I think that it is a nice starting point. Here's my suggestion with a few minor modifications:
getparams2 <- function(myp) {
m <- matrix(NA, nrow=length(myp), ncol=3)
for (i in (1:length(myp))){
m[i,] <- sapply(1:3,function(x) myp[[i]][[x]]#test$statistic)}
return(m)
}
This function represents a minor generalization in the sense that it allows for an arbitrary number of observations, while in your case this was fixed to two cases, a and b. The code can certainly be further shortened, but it might then also become somewhat more cryptic. I believe that in developing a code it is helpful to preserve a certain compromise between efficacy and compactness on one hand and readability or easiness to understand on the other.
Edit
As pointed out by #akrun and #Roland the function getparams2() can be written in a much more elegant and shorter form. One possibility is
getparams2 <- function(myp) {
matrix(unname(rapply(myp, function(x) x#test$statistic)),ncol=3)}
Another great alternative is
getparams2 <- function(myp){t(sapply(myp, sapply, function(x) x#test$statistic))}

Running the same function multiple times and saving results with different names in workspace

So, I built a function called sort.song.
My goal with this function is to randomly sample the rows of a data.frame (DATA) and then filter it out (DATA.NEW) to analyse it. I want to do it multiple times (let's say 10 times). By the end, I want that each object (mantel.something) resulted from this function to be saved in my workspace with a name that I can relate to each cycle (mantel.something1, mantel.somenthing2...mantel.something10).
I have the following code, so far:
sort.song<-function(DATA){
require(ade4)
for(i in 1:10){ # Am I using for correctly here?
DATA.NEW <- DATA[sample(1:nrow(DATA),replace=FALSE),]
DATA.NEW <- DATA.NEW[!duplicated(DATA.NEW$Point),]
coord.dist<-dist(DATA.NEW[,4:5],method="euclidean")
num.notes.dist<-dist(DATA.NEW$Num_Notes,method="euclidean")
songdur.dist<-dist(DATA.NEW$Song_Dur,method="euclidean")
hfreq.dist<-dist(DATA.NEW$High_Freq,method="euclidean")
lfreq.dist<-dist(DATA.NEW$Low_Freq,method="euclidean")
bwidth.dist<-dist(DATA.NEW$Bwidth_Song,method="euclidean")
hfreqlnote.dist<-dist(DATA.NEW$HighFreq_LastNote,method="euclidean")
mantel.numnotes[i]<<-mantel.rtest(coord.dist,num.notes.dist,nrepet=1000)
mantel.songdur[i]<<-mantel.rtest(coord.dist,songdur.dist,nrepet=1000)
mantel.hfreq[i]<<-mantel.rtest(coord.dist,hfreq.dist,nrepet=1000)
mantel.lfreq[i]<<-mantel.rtest(coord.dist,lfreq.dist,nrepet=1000)
mantel.bwidth[i]<<-mantel.rtest(coord.dist,bwidth.dist,nrepet=1000)
mantel.hfreqlnote[i]<<-mantel.rtest(coord.dist,hfreqlnote.dist,nrepet=1000)
}
}
Could someone please help me to do it the right way?
I think I'm not assigning the cycles correctly for each mantel.somenthing object.
Many thanks in advance!
The best way to implement what you are trying to do is through a list. You can even make it take two indices, the first for the iterations, the second for the type of analysis.
mantellist <- as.list(1:10) ## initiate list with some values
for (i in 1:10){
...
mantellist[[i]] <- list(numnotes=mantel.rtest(coord.dist,num.notes.dist,nrepet=1000),
songdur=mantel.rtest(coord.dist,songdur.dist,nrepet=1000),
hfreq=mantel.rtest(coord.dist,hfreq.dist,nrepet=1000),
...)
}
return(mantellist)
In this way you can index your specific analysis for each iteration in an intuitive way:
mantellist[[2]][['hfreq']]
mantellist[[2]]$hfreq ## alternative
EDIT by Mohr:
Just for clarification...
So, according to your suggestion the code should be something like this:
sort.song<-function(DATA){
require(ade4)
mantellist <- as.list(1:10)
for(i in 1:10){
DATA.NEW <- DATA[sample(1:nrow(DATA),replace=FALSE),]
DATA.NEW <- DATA.NEW[!duplicated(DATA.NEW$Point),]
coord.dist<-dist(DATA.NEW[,4:5],method="euclidean")
num.notes.dist<-dist(DATA.NEW$Num_Notes,method="euclidean")
songdur.dist<-dist(DATA.NEW$Song_Dur,method="euclidean")
hfreq.dist<-dist(DATA.NEW$High_Freq,method="euclidean")
lfreq.dist<-dist(DATA.NEW$Low_Freq,method="euclidean")
bwidth.dist<-dist(DATA.NEW$Bwidth_Song,method="euclidean")
hfreqlnote.dist<-dist(DATA.NEW$HighFreq_LastNote,method="euclidean")
mantellist[[i]] <- list(numnotes=mantel.rtest(coord.dist,num.notes.dist,nrepet=1000),
songdur=mantel.rtest(coord.dist,songdur.dist,nrepet=1000),
hfreq=mantel.rtest(coord.dist,hfreq.dist,nrepet=1000),
lfreq=mantel.rtest(coord.dist,lfreq.dist,nrepet=1000),
bwidth=mantel.rtest(coord.dist,bwidth.dist,nrepet=1000),
hfreqlnote=mantel.rtest(coord.dist,hfreqlnote.dist,nrepet=1000)
)
}
return(mantellist)
}
You can achieve your objective of repeating this exercise 10 (or more times) without using an explicit for-loop. Rather than have the function run the loop, write the sort.song function to run one iteration of the process, then you can use replicate to repeat that process however many times you desire.
It is generally good practice not to create a bunch of named objects in your global environment. Instead, you can hold of the results of each iteration of this process in a single object. replicate will return an array (if possible) otherwise a list (in the example below, a list of lists). So, the list will have 10 elements (one for each iteration) and each element will itself be a list containing named elements corresponding to each result of mantel.rtest.
sort.song<-function(DATA){
DATA.NEW <- DATA[sample(1:nrow(DATA),replace=FALSE),]
DATA.NEW <- DATA.NEW[!duplicated(DATA.NEW$Point),]
coord.dist <- dist(DATA.NEW[,4:5],method="euclidean")
num.notes.dist <- dist(DATA.NEW$Num_Notes,method="euclidean")
songdur.dist <- dist(DATA.NEW$Song_Dur,method="euclidean")
hfreq.dist <- dist(DATA.NEW$High_Freq,method="euclidean")
lfreq.dist <- dist(DATA.NEW$Low_Freq,method="euclidean")
bwidth.dist <- dist(DATA.NEW$Bwidth_Song,method="euclidean")
hfreqlnote.dist <- dist(DATA.NEW$HighFreq_LastNote,method="euclidean")
return(list(
numnotes = mantel.rtest(coord.dist,num.notes.dist,nrepet=1000),
songdur = mantel.rtest(coord.dist,songdur.dist,nrepet=1000),
hfreq = mantel.rtest(coord.dist,hfreq.dist,nrepet=1000),
lfreq = mantel.rtest(coord.dist,lfreq.dist,nrepet=1000),
bwidth = mantel.rtest(coord.dist,bwidth.dist,nrepet=1000),
hfreqlnote = mantel.rtest(coord.dist,hfreqlnote.dist,nrepet=1000)
))
}
require(ade4)
replicate(10, sort.song(DATA))

R: Confusion with apply() vs for loop

I know that I should avoid for-loops, but I'm not exactly sure how to do what I want to do with an apply function.
Here is a slightly simplified model of what I'm trying to do. So, essentially I have a big matrix of predictors and I want to run a regression using a window of 5 predictors on each side of the indexed predictor (i in the case of a for loop). With a for loop, I can just say something like:
results<-NULL
window<-5
for(i in 1:ncol(g))
{
first<-i-window #Set window boundaries
if(first<1){
1->first
}
last<-i+window-1
if(last>ncol(g)){
ncol(g)->last
}
predictors<-g[,first:last]
#Do regression stuff and return some result
results[i]<-regression stuff
}
Is there a good way to do this with an apply function? My problem is that the vector that apply would be shoving into the function really doesn't matter. All that matters is the index.
This question touches several points that are made in 'The R Inferno' http://www.burns-stat.com/pages/Tutor/R_inferno.pdf
There are some loops you should avoid, but not all of them. And using an apply function is more hiding the loop than avoiding it. This example seems like a good choice to leave in a 'for' loop.
Growing objects is generally bad form -- it can be extremely inefficient in some cases. If you are going to have a blanket rule, then "not growing objects" is a better one than "avoid loops".
You can create a list with the final length by:
result <- vector("list", ncol(g))
for(i in 1:ncol(g)) {
# stuff
result[[i]] <- #results
}
In some circumstances you might think the command:
window<-5
means give me a logical vector stating which values of 'window' are less than -5.
Spaces are good to use, mostly not to confuse humans, but to get the meaning directly above not to confuse R.
Using an apply function to do your regression is mostly a matter of preference in this case; it can handle some of the bookkeeping for you (and so possibly prevent errors) but won't speed up the code.
I would suggest using vectorized functions though to compute your first's and last's, though, perhaps something like:
window <- 5
ng <- 15 #or ncol(g)
xy <- data.frame(first = pmax( (1:ng) - window, 1 ),
last = pmin( (1:ng) + window, ng) )
Or be even smarter with
xy <- data.frame(first= c(rep(1, window), 1:(ng-window) ),
last = c((window+1):ng, rep(ng, window)) )
Then you could use this in a for loop like this:
results <- list()
for(i in 1:nrow(xy)) {
results[[i]] <- xy$first[i] : xy$last[i]
}
results
or with lapply like this:
results <- lapply(1:nrow(xy), function(i) {
xy$first[i] : xy$last[i]
})
where in both cases I just return the sequence between first and list; you would substitute with your actual regression code.

Resources