Qt4/Opengl bindTexture in separated thread - qt

Question

I am trying to implemente a CoverFlow like effect using a QGLWidget, the problem is the texture loading process.
I have a worker (QThread) for loading images from disk, and the main thread checks for new loaded images, if it finds any then uses bindTexture for loading them into QGLContext. While the texture is being bound, the main thread is blocked, so I have a fps drop.
What is the right way to do this?

Answer 1

I have found that the default behaviour of bindTexture in Qt4 is extremelly slow:
bindTexture(image,target,format,LinearFilteringBindOption | InvertedYBindOption | MipmapBindOption)
using only the LinearFilteringBindOption in the binding options speeds up the things a lot, this is my current call:
bindTexture(image, GL_TEXTURE_2D,GL_RGBA,QGLContext::LinearFilteringBindOption);
more info here : load time for a 3800x2850 bmp file reduced from 2 seconds to 34 milliseconds
Of course, if you need mipmapping, this is not the solution. In this case, I think that the way to go is Pixel Buffer Objects.

Answer 2

Binding in the main thread (single QGLWidget solution):
decide on maximum texture size. You could decide it based on maximum possible widget size for example. Say you know that the widget can be at most (approximately) 800x600 pixels and the largest cover visible has 30 pixels margins up and down and 1:2 aspect ratio -> 600-2*30 = 540 -> maximum size of the cover is 270x540, e.g. stored in m_maxCoverSize.
scale the incoming images to that size in the loader thread. It doesn't make sense to bind larger textures and the larger it is, the longer it'll take to upload to the graphics card. Use QImage::scaled(m_maxCoverSize, Qt::KeepAspectRatio) to scale loaded image and pass it to the main thread.
limit the number of textures or better time spent binding them per frame. I.e. remember the time at which you started binding textures (e.g. QTime bindStartTime;) and after binding each texture do:
if (bindStartTime.elapsed() > BIND_TIME_LIMIT)
break;
BIND_TIME_LIMIT would depend on frame rate you want to keep. But of course if binding each one texture takes much longer than BIND_TIME_LIMIT you haven't solved anything.
You might still experience framerate drop while loading images though on slower machines / graphics cards. The rest of the code should be prepared to live with it (e.g. use actual time to drive animation).
Alternative solution is to bind in a separate thread (using a second invisible QGLWidget, see documentation):
2. Texture uploading in a thread.
Doing texture uploads in a thread may be very useful for applications handling large amounts of images that needs to be displayed, like for instance a photo gallery application. This is supported in Qt through the existing bindTexture() API. A simple way of doing this is to create two sharing QGLWidgets. One is made current in the main GUI thread, while the other is made current in the texture upload thread. The widget in the uploading thread is never shown, it is only used for sharing textures with the main thread. For each texture that is bound via bindTexture(), notify the main thread so that it can start using the texture.