I have seen other discussions raising this topic however I'm far from confident with the results I'm getting. I wonder if someone can add some more insight into this topic.
We want to dynamically load the correct contact details based on the visitor's state in Australia.
We are using IP 2 Location and went out to test the database. I posted on Facebook a request for everyone in New South Wales to click a link on my post, I stored the result. I understand this is based on trust but the results are fairly unconvincing!
RESULTS: http://www.digeratisolutions.com.au/resultsdata.txt
Has anybody got a solution that is bankable? Or should I not automate something like this? Seems useless if this case doesn't work.
I have also tried Google's location API and it thought I was in another state.
This isn't reliable. To the best of my knowledge, the only way to get geographic location from an IP is to look up the DNS or whois records and see what geographic location they give, if any. But there's no assurance that that's the actual geographical location of a given user. For a home user it's going to show the location of the ISP, not the user. For example I just tried that site you linked to and it said I was in Ann Arbor, Michigan, US, which is close but I am really in Monroe, Michigan, 40 miles away. For someone at a business location, it's a location entered by the business, which is often their headquarters or a network center, not necessarily the work location of the individual person. That can result in wildly inaccurate locations.
If you're talking contractual issues, I don't think a "maybe probably this is what state they're in" will work. It occurs to me that even if you had a method that was 100% accurate, it could at best tell you where the user is at that moment, which is not necessarily where they live or where their business is. What if someone lives near a state boundary, and he connects to your web site while eating lunch at a wifi hot spot across the state line?
I think you'd be better off to just ask the user to tell you where they live or where their office is located. You can save their answer in your own database. Last I checked Australia only had six states -- maybe you also need to allow the territories, whatever -- so it shouldn't be tough for someone to select the right one from a list. That doesn't seem like a hard question.
Related
I am working on a website that has a set of regular content for pretty much everyone. A few US state governments do not like the phrasing/implications of some of the content and would like to make sure that their states' residents are not able to see the regular content at all. The trouble is that these states are not my home state.
Most VPN solutions that I've found are about spoofing your location to make it appear that you are in a different country, and while many might have server locations in more than one US state, they are not the state(s) that I'm targeting.
Other than traveling to those states, or knowing someone in those states, what kind of options exist to test content as if I'm a resident of another state? I'm essentially looking for a VPN that is (or can be) US state specific, or some equivalent process.
For example, I have a normal corporate VPN, but is it possible to have IT set up alternate VPNs based in those states, such that connecting to "VPN 1" or "VPN 2" would make my traffic appear to be from those places instead of my home state? Would AWS have any kind of service/product that could assist?
Since your server is using Geo-IP to determine location, I would simply add some testing IPs to the database and associate them to the locations that you want to test. That way, you can use the IPs that you can control and test your system at your convenience.
No VPNs or fancy routing needed.
I am looking to create a website that generates content depending on your city location. The best Example I found was Craigslit.They generate a web domain name like https://yourcity.craigslist.org/ when you either click on the city or it locates where you are. I was just wondering if I could get some help on how to build something like that.
The web pages are created using a template that doesn't change, populated with data that is selected from a database server, using your location to lookup appropriate items.
The subdomain (your city) is usually defined in the DNS record, just like www. There would be an entry for chicago.craigslist.org, for example.
edit
If you're asking how they know where you are, they can take a guess based on your IP address, however this isn't very reliable. Google does this also, when getting you search results that could be localized.
So yeah, it is expected of you to type some stuff into google to (try) find your answer (like detect city from javascript will bring up a lot of results for your problem.)
But yeah you would use a service like https://ipstack.com/ to detect where you live, depending on where you live the accuracy increases. (EU has some rules and regulations that make it a lot less accurate than if you would be living in the US)
Once you have a database with content - For example craigslist has a database of second hand items sold by people from all over. When you connect to craigslist they ask a service where your request came from - then use some filter function based on your location to match the results.
Good luck
Your IP address can be used to make an educated guess as to where you are, but it's not very accurate. When providing you with search results that might be localised, Google also does this.To know more about creating a website like craigslist follow here
https://www.yarddiant.com/blog/classifieds/how-to-build-a-website-like-craigslist.html
Hi friends I've been looking around for the past few days on a way to find the geolocation of the BGP AS's, preferably through the use of some API. I've been using the ripestat API for the majority of my work on this, but it comes up inconclusive on some of the AS's, for example AS 10000. RIPE tells me the location is in JP. Which is sort of fine, I just would like to narrow it down more to like a city / postal code / etc if possible. Is there another API suited for this? or is it just a manual task of fixing all the information once gathered.
Alternatively, if it is possible to grab the IP address of the actual AS itself, and not the range, that would likely work as well.
IP Geolocation isn't nearly accurate enough to pinpoint an IP to a specific City/ZIP code. In many cases, IPs from the same block will be used across a large area in an ISP's control, so it's not possible to be very accurate. Autonomous Systems don't really have "an IP", as there's no one specific location of them.
If you're looking for the locations where they peer to other providers, you might want to check out PeeringDB.
There are two Swiss (.ch) websites, let's call them A and B. A is owned by me and B by a customer.
Because of legal data protection issues B is hosted in Switzerland and not allowed to store any user information abroad. Which means that software like Google Analytics is not available on B. A is a Swiss website but hosted in a (European) cloud.
Now we would like to find out how many common users we both have over the duration of 30 days. In short:
numberOfUsersA ∩ numberOfUsersB
For the sake of simplicity: Instead of users we are perfectly happy to measure common browsers.
What would you suggest is the simplest way to solve this problem?
First off all, best regards from Zurich/Zug :) Swiss people are everywhere...
I don't think you're correct that it's not legal to collect data in Switzerland at all (also abroad). As I'm working in the financial industry I know this topic very well and we also had to do a lot research to use GA at all.
It's always the question what and how you collect data. What you can't do - beside you got in upfront the permission of the user - is storing personal identifiable information. That's anyway not allowed by GA - you can't import/save in custom dimension/metrics for example email addresses.
Please check https://support.google.com/adsense/answer/6156630?hl=en as general basic information about this topic.
If you save the IP addresses via IP anonymization, you shouldn't run into problems if you're declaring this in your data-privacy statements. Take this approach: https://support.google.com/analytics/answer/2763052?hl=en
I'm not a lawyer and also not want to give you legal advises, but ours told us that's fine. If you are real paranoid about sending data to the USA - like we have to be - you can exclude your tracking from very sensitive forms.
To go back to your basic question, if you want to find this out via Google Analytics, your key is "cross domain tracking". Check https://support.google.com/analytics/answer/1034342?hl=en for more information in this direction.
The only work-around I have in my mind beside this, is if you start collecting browser-fingerprints yourself and then connect both collections over the finger prints together (that's not save, as your visitors will use more than one device/configuration). I personally would go for the IP anonimization, exclude very sensitive forms and ensure that your data-privacy declaration contains all necessary parts for and offer an opt-out option then you should be on the safe side.
All the best and TGIF :)
google has an API for downloading search suggestions:
https://www.google.com/support/enterprise/static/gsa/docs/admin/70/gsa_doc_set/xml_reference/query_suggestion.html
unfortunately, as far as i can tell, these results are specific to your location. for an analysis, i would like to be able to define the city/location that google thinks it is making the suggestion to. here's what happens when i scrape from dar es salaam, tanzania:
http://suggestqueries.google.com/complete/search?client=firefox&q=insurance
["insurance",["insurance","insurance companies in tanzania","insurance group of tanzania","insurance principles","insurance act","insurance policy","insurance act tanzania","insurance act 2009","insurance definition","insurance industry in tanzania"]]
i understand that a vpn would partially solve this issue, but only by giving me a different location and not lots of locations. is there a reasonable way to replicate this sort of thing quickly and easily from, say, the 100 largest cities in the united states?
confirmation that results differ within the usa-
thanks!
Google will use your IP and your location history (if turned on) to determine your location.
To be able to go around it, you can spoof your IP while logged off your google account (but I don't know if google will consider it a trial of hacking no matter what your intentions are).
Another way is to use Tor browser (even though it is not it's original purpose). You can configure tor to exit from a certain country using the Exitnode parameter in the torrc config file
As found in the docs:
ExitNodes node,node,…
A list of identity fingerprints, country codes, and address patterns of nodes to use as exit node
But if you want a fast way to do it, I don't think that's possible since google wants to know the real location of the users and have put a lot of effort into making such tricks fail.
The hl param for interface language changes the search results, but I can't tell if it's actually changing the location. For example:
http://suggestqueries.google.com/complete/search?client=chrome&q=why&hl=FR
Here's an example with 5 different values of hl:
http://jsbin.com/tusacufaza/edit?js,output