How to efficiently scale and crop images in an ASP.NET app? - asp.net

Question

We're having problems with an ASP.NET application which allows users to upload, and crop images. The images are all scaled to fixed sizes afterwards. We basically run out of memory when a large file is processed; it seems that the handling of JPEG is rather inefficient -- we're using System.Drawing.BitMap. Do you have any general advice, and perhaps some pointers to a more efficient image handling library? What experiences do you have?

Answer 1

I had the same problem, the solution was to use System.Drawing.Graphics to do the transformations and dispose every bitmap object as soon as I was finished with it. Here's a sample from my library (resizing) :
public Bitmap ApplyTo(Bitmap bitmap)
{
using (bitmap)
{
Bitmap newBitmap = new Bitmap(bitmap, CalculateNewSize(bitmap));
using (Graphics graphics = Graphics.FromImage(newBitmap))
{
graphics.SmoothingMode =
SmoothingMode.None;
graphics.InterpolationMode =
InterpolationMode.HighQualityBicubic;
graphics.CompositingQuality =
CompositingQuality.HighQuality;
graphics.DrawImage(
bitmap,
new Rectangle(0, 0, newBitmap.Width, newBitmap.Height));
}
return newBitmap;
}
}

Answer 2

I found imageresizer and its great. and good API. Works Great.
Downloaded from Visual studio 2010 Extension Manager: http://nuget.org/.
Easy Steps to download API in VS-2010:
1). Install Extension http://nuget.org/.
3). Find and Install ImageResizing
4).Then Code: (I m using here cropping. you can use any) Documentation on imageresizing.net
string uploadFolder = Server.MapPath(Request.ApplicationPath + "images/");
FileUpload1.SaveAs(uploadFolder + FileUpload1.FileName);
//The resizing settings can specify any of 30 commands.. See http://imageresizing.net for details.
ResizeSettings resizeCropSettings = new ResizeSettings("width=200&height=200&format=jpg&crop=auto");
//Generate a filename (GUIDs are safest).
string fileName = Path.Combine(uploadFolder, System.Guid.NewGuid().ToString());
//Let the image builder add the correct extension based on the output file type (which may differ).
fileName = ImageBuilder.Current.Build(uploadFolder + FileUpload1.FileName, fileName, resizeCropSettings, false, true);
Try!!! its very awsumm and easy to use. thanks.

Answer 3

A couple of thoughts spring to mind -
What size of images do you allow
your users to upload and can you
impose restrictions on this?
When you're using the
System.Drawing.Bitmap class, are you
remembering to dispose of it
correctly? We found one of the primary causes of System.OutOfMemoryException exceptions on our shared hosting platform was users not disposing of Bitmap objects correctly.
Kev

Answer 4

There was an older bug with .net that all images would default to 32 bits per pixel - at this size you can exhaust your memory pretty fast. Please use PixelFormat structure to make sure this is not the case for your problem.
This link might help: http://msdn.microsoft.com/en-us/library/aa479306.aspx

Answer 5

Do you perhaps have a stack trace to look at?
I have also done some image editing after a user has uploaded an image. The only problems that I ran into were restrictions on file upload size on the browsers and timeouts. But nothing related to .Net's libraries.
Something else to consider. If you are doing multiple images or have some dangerous looping somewhere then are you making sure to flush() and dispose() things.