java 8: map function w/ two stream inputs? [duplicate] - functional-programming

Question

In JDK 8 with lambda b93 there was a class java.util.stream.Streams.zip in b93 which could be used to zip streams (this is illustrated in the tutorial Exploring Java8 Lambdas. Part 1 by Dhananjay Nene). This function :
Creates a lazy and sequential combined Stream whose elements are the
result of combining the elements of two streams.
However in b98 this has disappeared. Infact the Streams class is not even accessible in java.util.stream in b98.
Has this functionality been moved, and if so how do I zip streams concisely using b98?
The application I have in mind is in this java implementation of Shen, where I replaced the zip functionality in the
static <T> boolean every(Collection<T> c1, Collection<T> c2, BiPredicate<T, T> pred)
static <T> T find(Collection<T> c1, Collection<T> c2, BiPredicate<T, T> pred)
functions with rather verbose code (which doesn't use functionality from b98).

Answer 1

I needed this as well so I just took the source code from b93 and put it in a "util" class. I had to modify it slightly to work with the current API.
For reference here's the working code (take it at your own risk...):
public static<A, B, C> Stream<C> zip(Stream<? extends A> a,
Stream<? extends B> b,
BiFunction<? super A, ? super B, ? extends C> zipper) {
Objects.requireNonNull(zipper);
Spliterator<? extends A> aSpliterator = Objects.requireNonNull(a).spliterator();
Spliterator<? extends B> bSpliterator = Objects.requireNonNull(b).spliterator();
// Zipping looses DISTINCT and SORTED characteristics
int characteristics = aSpliterator.characteristics() & bSpliterator.characteristics() &
~(Spliterator.DISTINCT | Spliterator.SORTED);
long zipSize = ((characteristics & Spliterator.SIZED) != 0)
? Math.min(aSpliterator.getExactSizeIfKnown(), bSpliterator.getExactSizeIfKnown())
: -1;
Iterator<A> aIterator = Spliterators.iterator(aSpliterator);
Iterator<B> bIterator = Spliterators.iterator(bSpliterator);
Iterator<C> cIterator = new Iterator<C>() {
#Override
public boolean hasNext() {
return aIterator.hasNext() && bIterator.hasNext();
}
#Override
public C next() {
return zipper.apply(aIterator.next(), bIterator.next());
}
};
Spliterator<C> split = Spliterators.spliterator(cIterator, zipSize, characteristics);
return (a.isParallel() || b.isParallel())
? StreamSupport.stream(split, true)
: StreamSupport.stream(split, false);
}

Answer 2

zip is one of the functions provided by the protonpack library.
Stream<String> streamA = Stream.of("A", "B", "C");
Stream<String> streamB = Stream.of("Apple", "Banana", "Carrot", "Doughnut");
List<String> zipped = StreamUtils.zip(streamA,
streamB,
(a, b) -> a + " is for " + b)
.collect(Collectors.toList());
assertThat(zipped,
contains("A is for Apple", "B is for Banana", "C is for Carrot"));

Answer 3

If you have Guava in your project, you can use the Streams.zip method (was added in Guava 21):
Returns a stream in which each element is the result of passing the corresponding element of each of streamA and streamB to function. The resulting stream will only be as long as the shorter of the two input streams; if one stream is longer, its extra elements will be ignored. The resulting stream is not efficiently splittable. This may harm parallel performance.
public class Streams {
...
public static <A, B, R> Stream<R> zip(Stream<A> streamA,
Stream<B> streamB, BiFunction<? super A, ? super B, R> function) {
...
}
}

Answer 4

Zipping two streams using JDK8 with lambda (gist).
public static <A, B, C> Stream<C> zip(Stream<A> streamA, Stream<B> streamB, BiFunction<A, B, C> zipper) {
final Iterator<A> iteratorA = streamA.iterator();
final Iterator<B> iteratorB = streamB.iterator();
final Iterator<C> iteratorC = new Iterator<C>() {
#Override
public boolean hasNext() {
return iteratorA.hasNext() && iteratorB.hasNext();
}
#Override
public C next() {
return zipper.apply(iteratorA.next(), iteratorB.next());
}
};
final boolean parallel = streamA.isParallel() || streamB.isParallel();
return iteratorToFiniteStream(iteratorC, parallel);
}
public static <T> Stream<T> iteratorToFiniteStream(Iterator<T> iterator, boolean parallel) {
final Iterable<T> iterable = () -> iterator;
return StreamSupport.stream(iterable.spliterator(), parallel);
}

Answer 5

Since I can't conceive any use of zipping on collections other than indexed ones (Lists) and I am a big fan of simplicity, this would be my solution:
<A,B,C> Stream<C> zipped(List<A> lista, List<B> listb, BiFunction<A,B,C> zipper){
int shortestLength = Math.min(lista.size(),listb.size());
return IntStream.range(0,shortestLength).mapToObj( i -> {
return zipper.apply(lista.get(i), listb.get(i));
});
}

Answer 6

The methods of the class you mentioned have been moved to the Stream interface itself in favor to the default methods. But it seems that the zip method has been removed. Maybe because it is not clear what the default behavior for different sized streams should be. But implementing the desired behavior is straight-forward:
static <T> boolean every(
Collection<T> c1, Collection<T> c2, BiPredicate<T, T> pred) {
Iterator<T> it=c2.iterator();
return c1.stream().allMatch(x->!it.hasNext()||pred.test(x, it.next()));
}
static <T> T find(Collection<T> c1, Collection<T> c2, BiPredicate<T, T> pred) {
Iterator<T> it=c2.iterator();
return c1.stream().filter(x->it.hasNext()&&pred.test(x, it.next()))
.findFirst().orElse(null);
}

Answer 7

I humbly suggest this implementation. The resulting stream is truncated to the shorter of the two input streams.
public static <L, R, T> Stream<T> zip(Stream<L> leftStream, Stream<R> rightStream, BiFunction<L, R, T> combiner) {
Spliterator<L> lefts = leftStream.spliterator();
Spliterator<R> rights = rightStream.spliterator();
return StreamSupport.stream(new AbstractSpliterator<T>(Long.min(lefts.estimateSize(), rights.estimateSize()), lefts.characteristics() & rights.characteristics()) {
#Override
public boolean tryAdvance(Consumer<? super T> action) {
return lefts.tryAdvance(left->rights.tryAdvance(right->action.accept(combiner.apply(left, right))));
}
}, leftStream.isParallel() || rightStream.isParallel());
}

Answer 8

Using the latest Guava library (for the Streams class) you should be able to do
final Map<String, String> result =
Streams.zip(
collection1.stream(),
collection2.stream(),
AbstractMap.SimpleEntry::new)
.collect(Collectors.toMap(e -> e.getKey(), e -> e.getValue()));

Answer 9

The Lazy-Seq library provides zip functionality.
https://github.com/nurkiewicz/LazySeq
This library is heavily inspired by scala.collection.immutable.Stream and aims to provide immutable, thread-safe and easy to use lazy sequence implementation, possibly infinite.

Answer 10

Would this work for you? It's a short function, which lazily evaluates over the streams it's zipping, so you can supply it with infinite streams (it doesn't need to take the size of the streams being zipped).
If the streams are finite it stops as soon as one of the streams runs out of elements.
import java.util.Objects;
import java.util.function.BiFunction;
import java.util.stream.Stream;
class StreamUtils {
static <ARG1, ARG2, RESULT> Stream<RESULT> zip(
Stream<ARG1> s1,
Stream<ARG2> s2,
BiFunction<ARG1, ARG2, RESULT> combiner) {
final var i2 = s2.iterator();
return s1.map(x1 -> i2.hasNext() ? combiner.apply(x1, i2.next()) : null)
.takeWhile(Objects::nonNull);
}
}
Here is some unit test code (much longer than the code itself!)
import org.junit.jupiter.api.Test;
import org.junit.jupiter.params.ParameterizedTest;
import org.junit.jupiter.params.provider.Arguments;
import org.junit.jupiter.params.provider.MethodSource;
import java.util.List;
import java.util.concurrent.atomic.AtomicInteger;
import java.util.function.BiFunction;
import java.util.stream.Collectors;
import java.util.stream.Stream;
import static org.junit.jupiter.api.Assertions.assertEquals;
class StreamUtilsTest {
#ParameterizedTest
#MethodSource("shouldZipTestCases")
<ARG1, ARG2, RESULT>
void shouldZip(
String testName,
Stream<ARG1> s1,
Stream<ARG2> s2,
BiFunction<ARG1, ARG2, RESULT> combiner,
Stream<RESULT> expected) {
var actual = StreamUtils.zip(s1, s2, combiner);
assertEquals(
expected.collect(Collectors.toList()),
actual.collect(Collectors.toList()),
testName);
}
private static Stream<Arguments> shouldZipTestCases() {
return Stream.of(
Arguments.of(
"Two empty streams",
Stream.empty(),
Stream.empty(),
(BiFunction<Object, Object, Object>) StreamUtilsTest::combine,
Stream.empty()),
Arguments.of(
"One singleton and one empty stream",
Stream.of(1),
Stream.empty(),
(BiFunction<Object, Object, Object>) StreamUtilsTest::combine,
Stream.empty()),
Arguments.of(
"One empty and one singleton stream",
Stream.empty(),
Stream.of(1),
(BiFunction<Object, Object, Object>) StreamUtilsTest::combine,
Stream.empty()),
Arguments.of(
"Two singleton streams",
Stream.of("blah"),
Stream.of(1),
(BiFunction<Object, Object, Object>) StreamUtilsTest::combine,
Stream.of(pair("blah", 1))),
Arguments.of(
"One singleton, one multiple stream",
Stream.of("blob"),
Stream.of(2, 3),
(BiFunction<Object, Object, Object>) StreamUtilsTest::combine,
Stream.of(pair("blob", 2))),
Arguments.of(
"One multiple, one singleton stream",
Stream.of("foo", "bar"),
Stream.of(4),
(BiFunction<Object, Object, Object>) StreamUtilsTest::combine,
Stream.of(pair("foo", 4))),
Arguments.of(
"Two multiple streams",
Stream.of("nine", "eleven"),
Stream.of(10, 12),
(BiFunction<Object, Object, Object>) StreamUtilsTest::combine,
Stream.of(pair("nine", 10), pair("eleven", 12)))
);
}
private static List<Object> pair(Object o1, Object o2) {
return List.of(o1, o2);
}
static private <T1, T2> List<Object> combine(T1 o1, T2 o2) {
return List.of(o1, o2);
}
#Test
void shouldLazilyEvaluateInZip() {
final var a = new AtomicInteger();
final var b = new AtomicInteger();
final var zipped = StreamUtils.zip(
Stream.generate(a::incrementAndGet),
Stream.generate(b::decrementAndGet),
(xa, xb) -> xb + 3 * xa);
assertEquals(0, a.get(), "Should not have evaluated a at start");
assertEquals(0, b.get(), "Should not have evaluated b at start");
final var takeTwo = zipped.limit(2);
assertEquals(0, a.get(), "Should not have evaluated a at take");
assertEquals(0, b.get(), "Should not have evaluated b at take");
final var list = takeTwo.collect(Collectors.toList());
assertEquals(2, a.get(), "Should have evaluated a after collect");
assertEquals(-2, b.get(), "Should have evaluated b after collect");
assertEquals(List.of(2, 4), list);
}
}

Answer 11

public class Tuple<S,T> {
private final S object1;
private final T object2;
public Tuple(S object1, T object2) {
this.object1 = object1;
this.object2 = object2;
}
public S getObject1() {
return object1;
}
public T getObject2() {
return object2;
}
}
public class StreamUtils {
private StreamUtils() {
}
public static <T> Stream<Tuple<Integer,T>> zipWithIndex(Stream<T> stream) {
Stream<Integer> integerStream = IntStream.range(0, Integer.MAX_VALUE).boxed();
Iterator<Integer> integerIterator = integerStream.iterator();
return stream.map(x -> new Tuple<>(integerIterator.next(), x));
}
}

Answer 12

AOL's cyclops-react, to which I contribute, also provides zipping functionality, both via an extended Stream implementation, that also implements the reactive-streams interface ReactiveSeq, and via StreamUtils that offers much of the same functionality via static methods to standard Java Streams.
List<Tuple2<Integer,Integer>> list = ReactiveSeq.of(1,2,3,4,5,6)
.zip(Stream.of(100,200,300,400));
List<Tuple2<Integer,Integer>> list = StreamUtils.zip(Stream.of(1,2,3,4,5,6),
Stream.of(100,200,300,400));
It also offers more generalized Applicative based zipping. E.g.
ReactiveSeq.of("a","b","c")
.ap3(this::concat)
.ap(of("1","2","3"))
.ap(of(".","?","!"))
.toList();
//List("a1.","b2?","c3!");
private String concat(String a, String b, String c){
return a+b+c;
}
And even the ability to pair every item in one stream with every item in another
ReactiveSeq.of("a","b","c")
.forEach2(str->Stream.of(str+"!","2"), a->b->a+"_"+b);
//ReactiveSeq("a_a!","a_2","b_b!","b_2","c_c!","c2")

Answer 13

If anyone needs this yet, there is StreamEx.zipWith function in streamex library:
StreamEx<String> givenNames = StreamEx.of("Leo", "Fyodor")
StreamEx<String> familyNames = StreamEx.of("Tolstoy", "Dostoevsky")
StreamEx<String> fullNames = givenNames.zipWith(familyNames, (gn, fn) -> gn + " " + fn);
fullNames.forEach(System.out::println); // prints: "Leo Tolstoy\nFyodor Dostoevsky\n"

Answer 14

This is great. I had to zip two streams into a Map with one stream being the key and other being the value
Stream<String> streamA = Stream.of("A", "B", "C");
Stream<String> streamB = Stream.of("Apple", "Banana", "Carrot", "Doughnut");
final Stream<Map.Entry<String, String>> s = StreamUtils.zip(streamA,
streamB,
(a, b) -> {
final Map.Entry<String, String> entry = new AbstractMap.SimpleEntry<String, String>(a, b);
return entry;
});
System.out.println(s.collect(Collectors.toMap(e -> e.getKey(), e -> e.getValue())));
Output:
{A=Apple, B=Banana, C=Carrot}